Leash training Great Danes is a challenge but SO important.
Teaching your Great Dane to walk politely on a leash is an important skill that can reduce your risk of injury, and theirs too!
Does your Great Dane pull a lot, choke themselves on their leash and embarrass you in public?
You’ve come to the right place! Here are our top 5 tips for leash training your Great Dane!
1. CHOOSE THE RIGHT GEAR
When leash training your Great Dane, we recommend starting with a flat buckle or martingale collar and a quality leash. (More info on no-pull tools is offered later in the blog!).
Martingale collars are escape proof and a great choice for dogs that easily back out of collars. (You can purchase beautiful, handmade martingale collars from Magnolia Mutts. She donates profits to Great Dane rescues).
Positive reinforcement is the best way to teach the dog what you want: in this case, walking by your side!
You can practice rewarding your dog after just one step, then two, then five and so on until you are confidently walking down the block. Keep the leash loose in your hands and encourage your dog to interact with you! Don’t worry, like any training tool, the goal here is to completely fade out the use of the treats. Take it easy and gradually replace treats with praise over time.
You can give your dog all the treats in the world, but it WILL NOT work if you are trying to train your dog when they are already distracted and pulling.
You must start your leash skills training indoors where the environment is predictable and boring.
Kind of like Kindergarten! Work at your dogs level and only approach college level requirements when your dog is actually ready for it. Thoroughly teach the ‘HEEL’ or ‘WITH ME’ commands so you can work your way up to doing those skills in a more distracting area. Set up an obstacle course in your house and practice loose leash walking around it!
4. KEEP PRACTICING
Work on your leash training skills for a few minutes each, several times per day both off-leash and on in your living room and fenced yard if you have one.
As your dog is better able to keep the leash loose and focus on you, offer lots of praise and work on this skill in a new (but still easy) area such as Home Depot (on a quiet day) or a quiet park. Remember, you can train your dog to ‘HEEL’ the same way you train any other trick. It’s just a game!
Make sure to allow your dog PLENTY of time to also sniff about and explore. This calm enrichment teaches them to be comfortable in the environment. Stay positive and aware of your surroundings AND your own behavior. Tension from you = tension from your dog.
5. LEARN ABOUT TRAINING TOOLS FOR GREAT DANES
Many people are curious about the best leash training tools for Great Danes. Here is our quick rundown on tools that can be used, but that must ALSO be paired with proper training mentioned above.
HEAD COLLAR
Head Collar: This popular tool relies on pressure to your dog’s face, making it very uncomfortable for the dog to pull. Many dogs find it to be aversive to wear and will paw at it, whine or even shut down. This option, if used, should be paired with diligent conditioning and training to prevent pulling in the first place, as a dog that lunges in a head collar can injure himself.
Head collars should never be used on dogs with entropion, cherry eye, poor structure (including incorrect head/neck/front assembly) or Wobblers. Contrary to popular belief, the ‘head collar’ or ‘gentle leader’ is not actually positive or gentle, and we believe that for most owners, this tool is not actually the best choice.
Prong Collar: This collar distributes pressure evenly around the dog’s neck. When used properly, a prong collar will not pop a balloon, and when applied to your arm will simply feel like pressure that goes away as soon as you release the tension.
They look scary but that doesn’t mean that they are. Prong collars are not aversive to wear, and with a few quick, positive conditioning exercises they become a cue to your dog to redirect and look at you for direction. The pressure, if needed, is safer and better for your dog than the pressure that they get when they pull wildly into a flat collar or harness.
When fit and used correctly, prong collars are a surprisingly gentle option, as they don’t rely on restrictions to movement or force. Many canine chiropractors advocate for prongs paired with positive reinforcement as the tool of choice, for a reason. We recommend working with a trainer, however. Jerking your dog around or purely relying on a prong collar to do the job is NOT how this tool works. Herm Sprenger brand is the only good choice.
NO PULL HARNESS
No-Pull Harness: No pull and front-clip harnesses rely on the same concept as prong collars and head collars; applying pressure that makes it uncomfortable to pull and rewarding to stop. No Pull Harnesses also alter the way a dog moves, may throw them off balance and will nearly always restrict the movement of the shoulders. We do not recommend the use of front clip harnesses such as ‘Easy Walk’ or ‘Petsafe’, and contrary to popular belief they are not a positive or dog-friendly option. The exception to harnesses may be an athletic fit y-front harness (shown below) with a front-clip, if necessary, and transition to back clip use.
CHAIN COLLAR
Chain Collar: Chain collars look cool, but they should not be used as a ‘necklace’. Trainers use them as an audible correction; they are not meant to choke the dog. The ‘zip’ of the chain sliding through the ring is enough to get most dogs attention, but it will not work if the dog is already pulling into the collar. We believe there are better choices, however for this option we recommend a martingale style chain (see below).
E-Collar – the modern high-quality E-Collar, when used properly, is more humane and less aversive than any other training tool (including no-pull harness and head collar) listed above. They CAN be used for leash skills, too, but you have to do it right. Read more in our E-Collar training guide here: https://www.hellodanes.com/product/great-dane-e-collar-training-guide/
ALL tools can be used incorrectly and result in pain, fear and downright abuse. It’s up to you to learn about each tool before using it on your dog. Tread cautiously with marketing that is meant to make you believe that ‘nylon’ tools are positive and metal tools are abusive and punishing! It’s not that simple.
The information contained in this post is for informational purposes only. We do our best to present the most up-to-date research, however it is up to the reader to make decisions regarding the health and well-being of their dog. We make no claims here to prevent or treat bloat or any other condition related to Great Danes. Find a veterinarian with GIANT breed experience, and chat with them.
Some of the products we list on our website contain affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase, we may receive a small commission for referring you. This commission does not affect the price of the product and is used to fund this website and our content.
Today we are giving you our detailed, unpaid Halo Dog Collar review! The Halo Collar is a dog training collar that in theory, allows your dog to be off-leash anywhere you go. If you’ve found this popular post on our site, awesome! That means you are a dedicated pet owner looking to safely and humanely get your pup off-leash. We love that!
People are interested in the Halo Dog training collar (and now the Halo 3 for dogs) because it offers something no other device has yet: automated boundaries for your dog using a phone app. Allow me to clarify:
The idea is amazing. Put this Halo Collar on your dog, draw a boundary on a map in the phone app, and the collar will keep your dog inside of the boundary (with some training, of course!).
Imagine the possibilities! This is an idea that many people have asked about but no company had done gracefully yet. Many other similar boundary collars and invisible fences for dogs are clunky, huge, and unreliable. Underground boundary fences can be hard to install (not to mention expensive!). Worse, many other off-leash training fences utilize painful shocks that cause dogs to scream and fear being in the yard.
The Halo Dog Collars are marketed as a modern, more humane, and more effective alternative to traditional invisible shock fences.
The difference between a Halo 3 collar and an invisible fence is huge.
We were DEFINITELY intrigued and know that a lot of Great Dane owners are asking about Halo, Halo 2+, and Halo 3 Collar reviews.
This is our review of the HALO dog Collar by Cesar Milan. Is this a Halo Collar buyer beware, or a Halo Collar buyer buy it? Read on, friends…
Does the Halo 3 Dog Collar Shock the Dog?
The Halo Dog Collar uses tone, voice corrections, and stimulation.
Stimulation is an electrical current that causes the muscle to twitch. Think of this like a tactile sensation, no different than leash tension or touch. When used at low levels, muscle stimulation can be used as a positive tactile communication. This sensation is not the same as ‘shock’ and should not cause negative associations or feelings for dogs that are trained properly to understand what it means.
On the other hand, when used at high levels, muscle stimulation is an aversive sensation that can be used as a correction. However, at low levels, it is an incredible tool that replaces leash tension.
Think of it this way:
Shock = sharp poke with a stick Low level stimulation = gentle leash pressure High level stimulation = stronger leash pressure + squeeze pressure from a collar
Shock (which is intended to be painful) and stimulation (which is intended to be a gentle tactile sensation) are two different things.
While Halo pet collar did NOT pioneer modern stimulation like what is used in E-Collar technologies e-collars, they are using stimulation (not shock) in the Halo, Halo 2, and Halo 3 collar. Modern stimulation collars are the ONLY kind we recommend, so Halo gets 5 stars from us for this!
Halo Dog Containment Systems Reviews – What is the Halo Dog Collar?
The Halo, Halo 2, and Halo 3 Dog collar is an automated E-Collar. It uses sound, vibration, and electronic stimulation to teach and reinforce invisible boundaries. This can keep your dog safe while off-leash!
Imagine this. You create a virtual fence using the Halo App on your phone. In this example, you might draw a map that is meant to keep your dog on your front lawn.
As your dog approaches the boundary of the edge of the lawn, the collar lets the dog know that they are nearing it. If the dog chooses to disregard the first communication, the collar can use stimulation (a form of pressure) to discourage continued movement towards the boundary. It will then reward them for turning away from the boundary (back onto your lawn, yay!).
From what we understand, the user has a lot of control over how corrections are implemented and used. This is very helpful because every dog is different!
The collar will, with training, keep your dog inside of that invisible fence. This could be very helpful technology! We definitely like the concept.
If your dog gets out of the boundary that you set, despite warnings and corrections, a feature it built in that will allow you to find your dog with the included GPS tracker. This is a nice feature.
The Halo collar retails for nearly $1000 (yes, you read that correctly!) but is occasionally seen offered at around $699.
2023 Update: The Halo 3 has been released with updates to the GPS capabilities and overall build.
Is There a Monthly Fee for the Halo Collar?
Yes, there is a monthly fee associated with the Halo Collar app.
We have noticed that it’s something many buyers are VERY surprised by!
The monthly fees to use the required app are an additional cost. Without a paid monthly subscription, the features of the Halo Dog Collar are very limited.
The Cesar dog collar comes in two colors and three sizes; the largest size Collar expands to 30.5″ and may or may not fit a giant breed dog. Measure your dogs neck before ordering!
Now, if you have spent any time on our site, you know that we support ethical, positive, and humane E-Collar use.
We are not going to have any issue at all with the concept of the Halo Collar as an electric training device. Keeping a dog safe by using tactile electric communication is one of the most gentle, humane, and responsible things dog owners can do.
How Well Does the Halo Collar Work?
The idea behind the Halo Collar is that it automates boundary training. It’s kind of like a modern ‘invisible fence’.
The Halo marketing department focuses heavily on this tool easily giving dogs off-leash freedom anywhere you go. How cool would it be to go camping, and be able to keep your pup on your campsite?
It’s important to note that all training devices require diligent training and conditioning. The Halo, Halo 2, and Halo 3 are no exception. Do not expect to put this collar on your dog and be quickly and easily safely off leash anywhere you go.
Because it works on GPS and a phone APP, your dog’s safety relies on the system not experiencing a technical failure of some kind.
As with ANY training tool, it also relies on your ability to follow the training instructions and work with your dog on a regular basis.
If the Halo 3 collar gps system is functioning and you’ve spent time teaching your dog how to respond to the communications from the Halo Collar, it can absolutely work beautifully!
The Halo Dog Collar by Cesar Milan
People are Talking: Real-Life Halo Dog Collar Reviews
Unfortunately, there have reports from people that their smart off-leash dog collar has broken, stopped functioning, doesn’t work, and is cheaply made.
A lot of people on Youtube cite that the original Halo collar is made primarily of weak plastic parts which may fail and leave your dog unprotected. Halo made improvements to their dog off-leash collar with the Halo 2, and we are optimistic that the Halo 3 is a game changer!
JUNE 2022 UPDATE: We’ve read that Halo has supposedly completely fixed and updated many reported issues.
If you are looking to purchase a Halo Collar for your dog, you should in theory feel much more confident in the newer model. We are giving this some time before updating our review with information about the quality and consistency of the newer version.
GPS Automation Failures on the Halo Wireless Fence
There have been some reports out there that the GPS aspect of the collar, on the original and currently updated version, can at times be unreliable. This is largely related to the nature of technology and GPS.
Normally we say to stay away from cheap shock collars….but this device isn’t cheap! We believe that a solid amount of technology and research has gone into this device.
How the Halo Dog Training Collar Works
IF the Halo collar is actually functioning properly with a strong, reliable GPS connection to the ‘fence’ you built in the app, you do still have to work on training.
Don’t be made to believe that this is an ‘easy fix’ to a well-trained dog.
Proper conditioning and training are important with any training tool, including harnesses, so this is to be expected. However, this training should be fun and easy!
The Cesar dog collar functions by using a tone or audible voice and then static (muscle stimulation) to remind dogs to turn away from a boundary.
The company does say you have to train your dog how to respond to the collar, and the app walks you through the process. It’s automated, but not automatic.
Once your dog understands how to respond to the communication from the collar, you should be able to draw a boundary and have your dog understand it, almost anywhere that you go.
The collar will issue sounds, verbal communications, and static stimulation as needed to direct your dog into the boundary.
Is the Halo Collar Worth It?
The price of the Halo Dog Collar is premium, there is no question about that. For some dog owners, this is cost prohibitive. A simple long leash can accomplish a similar thing for much, much less.
As before, we are hopeful that recent updates to their device will give millions of dogs a valuable opportunity to be off-leash! The Halo Collar may be the ideal solution for you if:
You don’t have a fence
You regularly visit people where there is no fence
You like to go camping and want your dog to stay within a boundary of the tent site
You want a simple, user-friendly training tool
You don’t mind automating parts of your off-leash training
You have a dog that likes to learn, likes to be near you and already has a least a basic recall
Your pet is not reactive or aggressive, or has reactivity that is well managed
SUMMARY
Now that you’ve read our Halo Dog Collar review, would you buy one?
Do we think you should buy a Halo dog collar?
Do we believe that the Halo 3 for Dogs is a solid update to what was previously a somewhat unreliable product?
I am optimistic in my belief that the Halo Dog Collar is a great choice for many pet owners. We LOVE that they no longer focus so much on their relationship with Cesar Milan (a very controversial dog trainer), and that they are continually improving their products.
The main reason we’d recommend a HALO collar is for people who cannot build a physical fence around their property and want something slightly more flexible than a traditional invisible fence.
Halo Dog Treats Reviews
Are Halo dog treats legit? Some people confuse the Halo Collar with the Halo dog food and dog treats company.
We do not recommend Halo Dog food, but the treats may be ok!
Many people view E-Collars (sometimes called ‘shock collars) as an ‘Easy button’ meant to startle and punish a dog that is acting out. This is labeled as ‘aversive’ training and rightfully so.
The belief that this is how all E-Collars are used is unfortunately what gives E-Collars a BAD name, however. It’s important to note that a heavy-handed, aversive, forceful punishment-based approach is the exact opposite of how an E-Collar should be used.
Today we are dispelling some common MYTHS about E-Collars and E-Collar training, so that you can make an informed decision.
MYTH # 1: SHOCK COLLARS AND E-COLLARS ARE THE SAME THING
E-Collars and Shock collars look similar but they are very, very different tools.
E-Collars provide a blunt, tactile muscle stimulation that feels like ants marching or a gentle tingle, and 100 levels to choose from.
Shock collars provide a sharp static correction is meant to HURT, with only a few levels to choose from.
If your goal is to hurt, startle, scare or intimidate your dog like they did back in 2001 I suppose a shock collar will work just fine. But shock collars SUCK. They deserve their sketchy reputation.
Proper E-Collars run $180 or MORE. They cannot be compared to or used the same way as cheap garbage shock collars from Amazon.
Read on…
MYTH #2: E-COLLARS MAKE DOGS FEARFUL AND ANXIOUS
Incorrectly used shock collars can absolutely make a dog fearful, anxious or even aggressive.
But so can incorrectly used head harnesses, no-pull harnesses, squirt bottles, crates and even LEASHES!
Every single training tool, including those often labeled as ‘positive’ can be harmful or hurtful to a dog if used incorrectly.
Confusing, punishment based restrictive training methods including intimidation and ‘Alpha/Dominance’ are what lead to fear, anxiety and aggression.
The tactile communication from a properly used E-Collar is more gentle than the tactile communication from a leash, no-pull harness, head collar, or tension on the neck from pulling.
That’s a fact, and one that tends to surprise a lot of people.
MYTH #3: E-COLLARS ARE EXTREMELY AVERSIVE
Let’s compare a popular ‘positive’ dog training tool to a properly used E-Collar.
HEAD COLLAR. Head collars cause many dogs to paw, whine, become frantic or shut down.
It is a rare dog who will accept a head collar without having a problem with it straight out of the gate. Halti and Gentle Leaders rely on tactile pressure, even just by being worn.
Head collars require counter-conditioning and desensitization that often takes days or weeks. The dog will always experience constant pressure from the head collar and may injure themselves if they pull or lunge against it, even just to sniff the ground.
Head collars are considered a ‘friendly’ tool and are used by many ‘positive’ trainers despite the fact that they rely heavily on positive punishment and pressure. The same thing is true when it comes to front-clip and no-pull harnesses., which also rely on pressure/punishment and obstructing the way a dog moves. These are NOT ‘positive’ or ‘force-free’ tools.
E-COLLAR. E-Collars are introduced at a low level and paired with treats. Dogs do not shut down, become frantic or show signs of fear. Instead, they feel the stimulation and become very excited about it, all within minutes of being fully introduced to the tool! They know that the gentle stim = treats and good things.
This gentle stimulation is a tactile/touch sensation that feels like tiny ants crawling on the skin and can be used to communicate to the dog that redirecting back to the handler and ignoring distractions that cause lunging, barking or pulling is always a good thing.
I don’t know about you, but I’d MUCH rather feel a small occasional tingle (that I know how to respond to and know means good things when I do) than to spend my life restricted from natural movement with a long leash or a bunch of webbing clipped onto my chest or face.
MYTH #4: YOU CAN’T USE AN E-COLLAR AND STILL CLAIM TO BE POSITIVE
I suppose this is true if we are talking about those whom rely on shock, vibrate or high-level stim as an ‘easy button’ corrective tool.
We don’t support such unethical E-Collar use at all.
Slapping an electric collar on a dog and using it straight up as a corrective tool is NOT humane, ethical, positive or appropriate. We agree!
In the last decade, HUGE strides have been made in dog training and the modern E-Collar is not used that way AT ALL.
Basically put, dog trainers, dog owners and rescues who believe that all E-Collar training involves zapping a dog every time it reacts or steps out of line are uneducated about E-Collar training and unwilling to have an open mind about it.
The trainers who are doing E-Collar training correctly include people such as Larry Krohn and Tyler Muto, who use a hugely positive approach (lots of treats, praise, games and confidence building) and teach the E-Collar as a communication tool for off-leash reliability, not a correction tool.
They believe, as we do, that all foundational skills must first be taught without the E-Collar: sit, down, leave it, drop it, wait, come, place, stay and touch.
They also believe that it is completely inappropriate to ‘light a dog up‘ for emotional and fear based reactivity, including barking, lunging, aggression and leash aggression.
Run from any trainer who tells you to use the E-Collar to teach basic behaviors and then use it to ‘correct’ them with stim for not complying. That is NOT appropriate E-Collar training and IS the reason why this tool has such a negative reputation.
What does E-Collar training actually look like?
The first step is to condition the dog to the stimulation, by teaching them that it means really, really good things. Remember, this stimulation, for a large majority of dogs (even big, powerful Danes) is less than most humans can feel!
If you watch the body language of a dog being conditioned to an E-Collar, you see loose posture, wagging tail, eye contact, drive and excitement. After a few repetitions, they feel the stim and become VERY excited and run to the handler.
Not unlike clicker training. Interesting.Unfortunately, MANY unethical trainers and uneducated dog owners completely skip the conditioning step and see the tool as a correction device for frustrating behaviors, and that’s unfortunate.
When done correctly, the E-Collar becomes the leash and in many ways, is less aversive, less restrictive, and less harmful than a leash (especially if the dog pulls or lunges). In the first session with the E-Collar, most dogs learn quickly that stim = follow/come/be with me and they LOVE IT.
No leash pressure, no tension, no stress on the neck, chest or shoulders. The dog is free to move naturally and is simply asked, through a gentle stimulation and treats, to be responsive to the handler. They are not being corrected or punished, either.
It’s interesting how that is considered ‘forceful’ and damaging. We believe it’s simply ignorance and a lack of education, or people who prefer to outright judge, have a closed mind and are unwilling to learn about this.
MYTH #5: E-COLLARS HURT THE DOG
Modern E-Collars (view them here) have 100 levels of stimulation that can be increased incrementally.
Most dogs respond to stimulation levels of 10 or less.
For perspective, it’s important to understand that most humans cannot even feel the stimulation until it’s been set at a level of 12 or higher.
A stimulation level of 6 or 7 is almost imperceptible. The sensation is so gentle that it is completely non-aversive. If it were hurting the dog, the dog being trained would show signs of stress. If a dog shows signs of stress while being trained, something is not being done correctly.
At worst, the stimulation from an E-Collar may be seen as mildly annoying to the dog. Which, a harness, leash, long line, head collar or keeping a door shut until the dog sits calmly may produce the same feelings.
The dog knows (through conditioning) how to quickly get rid of the tingling sensation. They are in control and can easily get rid of the ‘annoying’ thing. They also know that getting rid of it means treats and praise!
That head collar or long leash though? There is nothing they can do about those. They stay, whether the dog likes it or not.
MYTH #6 – E-COLLARS ARE UNNECESSARY
There is this idea out there that because a recall can be taught without an E-Collar, it should be and that there is no reason to add a tool to the mix.
But the truth is, when done correctly, E-Collar trained dogs are enthusiastic, happy, calm and often offered more freedom and autonomy than many other dogs.
How anybody can see that and say those dogs are abused is beyond us.
The E-Collar is an invisible leash. It gives an extra step of security on top an already outstanding, positively trained recall.
So is it ‘necessary’? No. Is it extremely helpful and beneficial when it comes to safety and giving a dog additional freedom? YES.
If a positive-only trained recall is blown off, there is no backup.
The E-Collar is a great safety device. Positive-trained dogs would benefit from knowing and understand E-Collar stimulation for this reason. To go without is like riding without a seatbelt.
The E-Collar provides a gentle, crystal clear communication to the dog from a distance, which ultimately allows for much more freedom. The tactile sensation can be used to communicate to a dog that it needs to come back, walk away from somebody else on the path, or has gone too far away. It can be used in an emergency, if the dog decides to chase a squirrel into traffic.
A higher level of stimulation is less harmful in that last situation than if the dog were to hit the end of a long leash and be jammed up by the neck as a result.
This is especially true for dogs that need to move naturally and explore in order to feel enriched.
‘Shocking’ and punishing a dog for blowing off a recall is NOT HOW IT WORKS. Applying a gentle tactile stimulation that they know how to respond to (come back and it goes away) IS how it works.
Interestingly enough, if you condition a dog correctly to the E-Collar, you rarely if ever have to use it. It’s not this ‘abusive’ tool of force that some people like to say it is.
MYTH #7 – STUDIES SHOW E-COLLARS CAUSE STRESS
Not a single one of those studies, that we’ve found, studied dogs where the dog was conditioned to the E-Collar first and trained with a lot of positive reinforcement.
Shock and startle training will absolutely cause stress. Cheap shock collars CAUSE STRESS. Stimming dogs for messing up, especially when they don’t know what’s being asked of them, will CAUSE STRESS.
Many of those studies lump shock collars and E-Collars together as the same tool; which they aren’t. The studies are not peer-reviewed. They are often biased and always extremely flawed.
Yet, people continue to cite them…even trainers who claim to be ‘science-based’. There is nothing science-based about citing studies that were not correctly done.
Watch this video of Larry Krohn conditioning a dog to the E-Collar. Please send us an email and tell us where this dog is stressed, anxious or being forced.
MYTH #8: VIBRATE IS BETTER THAN ‘SHOCK’
Most shock collars and E-Collars come with a ‘vibrate’ function.
Many dog owners believe that ‘vibrate’ is a gentle way to correct their dog, and will proudly state that they use that and would ‘never use shock unless necessary’.
Remember, we believe that shock collars areabsolute garbage. So yeah, shocking a dog is not ok. That’s not E-Collar training and shock and startle is not the most effective training, either.
Newsflash, though…vibrate mode is super-duper aversive to most dogs.
Does it succeed in punishing a dog for a behavior? Yup. Does it redirect dogs? Sure. Does it make owners feel ‘good’ about using it? Unfortunately, yes.
Take your vibration collar and put it in the palm of your hand to experience it. Have somebody else randomly hit the vibrate button when you aren’t paying attention. It’s really annoying and startling.
Take a PROPER E-Collar (like the Educator series) and put it on a level 7 (average stim where most dogs enthusiastically work). Feel it on your body somewhere. Heck, bump it up to a 14 and try again.
Tell me which YOU would prefer.
Folks, vibration mode is bad.
READY TO GET STARTED?
We rely heavily on positive reinforcement AND we use E-Collars to give our dogs security in their off-leash adventures.
Hello Danes is an authorized distributor of E-Collar Technologies products, and we are here to help you train your Great Dane in a positive, ethical way. Imagine off-leash freedom and more.
Let’s do this! Shop our collection of high-quality E-Collars for Great Danes here, and use code ECOLLARMAGIC for $10 off. Our E-Collars ship directly from the manufacturer.
If your Great Dane puppy is growling, snarling or snapping to protect food, a bed or a toy, you’ve come to the right place!
Today we are talking about how to stop a Great Dane puppy from resource guarding, AND how to prevent resource guarding (protecting valued items such as food, toys, treats, people and spaces) in the first place.
It’s important to note that resource guarding is a natural behavior, and one that can also be dangerous, especially as Great Danes grow to be so large.
Read on for more information!
WORST ADVICE EVER
Allow me to share with you the absolute WORST advice that you can give or receive, when it comes to preventing and treating resource guarding.
DO NOT DO THESE THINGS:
Stick your hands in the bowl and mess with the food so the dog gets ‘used to it’
Have children mess with the dog’s food
Take bones and treats away from the dog and give them back, so the dog learns to give it up
Have children take bones and treats from the dog for the same reason
Hit, whap, alpha roll, scold, pinch, jab, intimidate, correct or punish a dog that is guarding an item.
There. We said it. That old advice is BAD.
We are seriously OVER IT with these outdated, misguided and dangerous old ideas.
Why is that?
Because every single one of those things can actually causeand increaseresource guarding! If you want to get bit by your Great Dane, this is how you (or your children) get bit.
Read on for more scientific, up-to-date training information on resource guarding and Great Danes!
SUBTLE SIGNS OF RESOURCE GUARDING
Growls and snapping are rarely out of the blue. Watch for these cues, in escalating order:
Stiffness, breath holding
‘Side-Eye’, lip licking
Cowering, hunching over
Averting the head away or using it to ‘hide’ the item, including running away with it
Dogs most often guard food and high value treats such as bones and chews. However, they can guard toys, bedding, furniture. and even people!
Many people believe that their dog is protecting them, when the reality is that dog may be resource guarding them. Keep this in mind if you see some of these behaviors popping up in your own dog.
Some dogs are more prone to resource guarding than others, especially dogs from poorly-tempered parents, unethical breeders, bad breeding situations and many rescue situations.
It is a natural instinct that according to science, has literally NOTHING to do with ‘dominance’.
PREVENT RESOURCE GUARDING
The first step to preventing a Great Dane puppy from resource guarding in the first place is to make sure that the behavior is not practiced.
Give your dog a safe space to eat, get away from chaos, and enjoy high-value treats and bones.
Don’t give your dog a reason to guard items in the first place. No pressure, no intimidation, no messing with it.
Teach your dog that you approaching them when they have food or treats is a positive thing!
Don’t use old techniques that prove to them, without a doubt, that their concerns about you taking things away are valid.
Teach positive behavior skills (see below).
ALWAYS TRADE UP
If you approach your puppy that is eating, simply walk by and drop a high value treat, such as boiled chicken from your pocket. Walk off, no big deal.
The young dog quickly learns that you coming into their space while they eat is a positive thing. Watch the subtle body language and use your judgement. After a few repetitions, you can take your hand and place the chicken in the bowl while they eat, SAFELY, and your hand may actually be welcomed there!
That is, of course if you really think it’s *that* important to stick your hands in your dog’s food in the first place.
Hands in bowl = good things happen, not hands in bowl = bad things.
Contrary to popular belief, that bite of chicken is not rewarding the dog for guarding. It actually can’t, because that’s not how emotions and psychology works.
IT’S SO SIMPLE.
Studies show that confrontational training methods increase aggression.
It’s true. Many people may think they’ve been effective in shutting down a behavior problem by punishing a dog for growling, but what they’ve really done is taught the dog that growling is not an acceptable communication.
So the dog doesn’t growl. But what comes after growling? Oh that’s right…snarling, snapping and bites. The underlying behavior and emotion hasn’t been addressed, and the dog may become more unstable.
Confrontational, outdated training methods can make dogs less safe and less predictable, and that’s a scientifically proven fact.
TRAIN YOUR DOG. TEACH LEAVE IT AND DROP IT
Leave it and Drop it are effective communications to a dog that mean so much more than just shouting ‘NO’. All dogs should know these commands.
Leave it and Drop it are EASY to teach and will be especially important for dogs that seem to be more prone to resource guarding in the first place.
OFF is an important command for dogs that guard furniture and bedding.
OUT, BACK UP, PLACE or CRATE UP is a good command for dogs that guard people and spaces.
Manage your dog and teach them boundaries from a young age. Do not allow these behaviors to develop or to be practiced in the first place.
Need resources for teaching those commands? YOUTUBE has a wealth of information. We recommend Kikopup, Larry Krohn and Steve Mann.
A dog cannot resource guard if they’ve been given clear communication about what they SHOULD be doing instead. Training these commands is a key piece in establishing harmony and safety between dogs and humans.
THINK OF IT THIS WAY
You are starving and have a piece of pizza.
I walk up, take it from you, mess with it, and give it back. I jab you in the side and tell you to shut up when you yell at me for it.
How do you feel about me? How do you feel about me approaching you the next time you have food?
NEW SCENARIO
Let’s try this again. You have pizza and are concerned I may take it.
I walk by and give you $5. FREE. Dropped on the floor at your feet. A few hours later, I do it again.
Did I just reward you for your concerns, or are you starting to believe that me coming by when you have pizza is quite alright?
DOGS ARE NOT DUMB AND MODERN BEHAVIOR SCIENCE IS REALLY, REALLY COOL.
If you have a dog that is already resource guarding and showing signs of being unsafe around humans, children or other dogs we highly recommend doing the following things:
a. Contact your breeder, if your dog was purchased. They should know that resource guarding may be happening in their lines, and may have (hopefully modern) advice to give.
b. QUICKLY contact a trainer and get professional help.
c. Prevent the behavior by limiting access to guarded items and providing a safe space for dogs to eat and relax. This may mean no more bones, no access to the couch, etc.
d. Train and install other behaviors: off, leave it, drop it, crate, wait, etc.
e. Stop fussing with the dog and trying to ‘correct’ or fix the behavior.
The truth is that sometimes, we actually cause this behavior to increase by putting too much pressure onto them.
Now, of course you don’t want an aggressive dog! This is exactly why preventing the behavior and lowering the stress surrounding the emotions that cause it is the most important step. Don’t increase aggression by being confrontational.
DON’T CREATE A GUARDING PROBLEM.
Here is a wonderful video from balanced dog trainer Larry Krohn on resource guarding that addresses EVERYTHING we mentioned in this post today.
We will also provide information on how to choose the right e-collar for your dog and how to use it safely, humanely, and effectively.
Use our table of contents below to navigate (the headings are clickable!). This post is JAM PACKED with E-Collar information!
The Best E-Collars for Great Danes
5 Reasons to Choose E-Collar Training for your Giant Breed Dog
At Hello Danes we believe in modern, humane, positive E-Collar training. Here are 5 quick reasons to choose this for your pet!
Unlike harnesses, collars, and leashes, the E-Collar uses absolutely no physical pressure or restraint.
This can be very important when you have a large, strong dog like the Great Dane! Not only that, but a Great Dane’s neck is very sensitive. We should not be relying heavily on any tools or leash attachment points that add ongoing physical pressure to the neck, chest, face, or back.
E-Collar training is also very versatile.
You can use it for obedience training, recall, behavior modification, safety, boundaries, and more.
E-Collars are also very safe, gentle, and humane when used properly.
We are providing you with tons of training tips in this post, or visit our famous Great Dane E-Collar training guide!
Remote-collar trained dogs are a joy to take on hikes, walks, and trips to the dog park.
E-Collar training gives you the freedom to enjoy your dog without having to worry about them running off or getting into trouble.
E-Collar training is a fun, positive experience for your dog!
If you’ve found our blog post today you may be wondering if choosing a shock or E-Collar for your Great Dane is even the right choice.
Chances are, you are feeling frustrated or overwhelmed by your Great Dane and some behavioral issues, including running off, jumping the fence, barking, and eating off the counter.
Or maybe you are hoping to improve recall and give your dogoff-leash freedom.
Perhaps you heard that training tools like this (or prong collars) were abusive, aversive, punishing, and harmful to your dog. (Pro-tip, this is NOT true!)
We hear you, friend! You are in the right place. Read on for more information (or check out some of our popular links below).
Modern E-Collars (the kind we recommend below) work by emitting a low level of stimulation to the dog’s neck.
The stimulation is similar to that of a medical-grade TENS unit. It does not zap or feel sharp, but rather feels like a tickle or muscle twitch.
This sensation completely replaces the physical pressure that your dog would otherwise feel from a leash, harness, or regular dog collar.
This virtual, wireless ‘pressure’ can be used in a number of ways to communicate with your dog from a distance.
As an added bonus, it cannot cause your dog ANY physical harm or orthopedic damage from pulling into a leash, harness, or dog collar. This truly is the most gentle and effective way to train your giant breed dog.
SHOCK COLLARS are different. These antiquated training tools rely on static to sharply ‘zap’ the dog, not unlike a cattle prod, hot wire fence, or sticking your wet finger in a plug socket.
The goal of a shock collar is to punish the dog for doing something wrong.
Shock is startling and often painful. These devices are cheap and easy to find on Amazon or even the local pet store
The cheaper the shock collar, the more likely it is to be unreliable (including shocking dogs at too high of a level or otherwise malfunctioning).
We do not recommend shock collars or old-style shock collar training for any reason.
Read on to learn about the more modern, effective, humane choice: E-Collars.
Have your dog calmly ignore dogs and people walking by
Stop lunging and jumping
Keep your dog safely behind an invisible boundary
Stop fence jumping, once and for all
Put an end to nuisance barking
Stop counter surfing
Redirect your dog away from rude social interactions
Immediately recall your dog to you in an emergency
All without pain, fear or frustration.
We are here to be a resource for you when it comes to all things E-Collar, positive dog training, and more.
A well-trained Great Dane is happier, healthier and a joy to live with!
We do not recommend the purchase of any cheap shock collar for any reason. Cheap shock collars are made to punish, and E-Collars are made to communicate.
We highly recommend E-Collar Technologies Educator series collars (ET-300, ET-400 and ET-900 models).
While we do offer them in our store ($10 off with code ECOLLARMAGIC), you can also buy them directly from the manufacturer. Amazon may have knockoffs or outdated models, so buyer beware.
We love these collars because they have pioneered modern off-lead dog training, and developed a proprietary tapping sensation that doesn’t hurt, punish, scare or harm your dog.
We will be covering each model’s features and pricing below so that you can choose the best training collar for your dog.
The Mini-Educator (300), the Educator (400) and the EZ Educator (900) models all offer adjustable stimulation levels from 1-100.
Most dogs will respond enthusiastically and work at levels 10-15 or less. The majority of humans can barely feel the stimulation, if at all, until level 8 or more!
Your dog will first be taught to have a positive association with this low-level sensation.
Our Top Pick for Beginners: the Mini-Educator
The Mini-Educator is our top pick for beginners because it is the most affordable option that still offers all of the features you need to get started with E-Collar training.
The Mini-Educator has a half-mile range and if you have two dogs, you can purchase a system with two collars!
The Mini-Educator remote collar is a simple, easy-to-use, and rugged system.
The receiver and remote are impact-resistant and waterproof, and features include adjustable stimulation, vibration sensation, tone, and night light.
Our Top Pick for Long-Distance Dogs: The Educator Collar
The Educator remote collar looks almost identical to the Mini-Educator but offers a bigger range (3/4 mile) than the Mini-Educator listed above.
The receiver and remote are rugged and waterproof, and features include adjustable stimulation, vibration sensation, tone, and night light.
The Educator is also available in a one or two-dog system if you have multiple dogs!
We recommend the Educator for Great Dane owners that need more range than the Mini-Educator (ET-300) series can offer but still prefer simplicity and ergonomics.
Choose the one or two-dog system below, and get started!
We are an authorizedE-Collar Technologies dealerand chose to work with this brand, not the others because it’s the one we believe in the most!
They have the best customer service and the most reliable E-Collars we’ve worked with.
When you order from Hello Danes, you are backed by Great Dane lovers and will receive the latest model collar directly from the manufacturer.
We are here to support you with all of your Great Dane, positive training, and E-Collar questions!
E-Collar Training Information & FAQ
Imagine reliably training your Great Dane using communication that you may barely be able to feel yourself.
Contrary to popular belief, you do NOT need to shock or scare your dog into obedience.
The E-Collar is a powerful tool that when used correctly, provides much more outstanding results than traditional shock collar training! EVEN with large, in-charge, and currently out-of-control dogs.
Of course, because the E-Collar is adjustable (100 different levels!) you can find the magic place where your dog responds. Then, you can easily utilize a stronger stimulation or the more aversive vibration sensation for the times when the dog is distracted or needs immediate redirection for safety reasons.
E-Collar training begins with teaching the dog to associate the stim feeling with positive things such as treats, praise, fun and attention. Not punishment!
Proper E-Collar training relies heavily on positive reinforcement. You can teach a dog MUCH faster if you first teach and reward them for the behavior that you want, and then use the E-Collar to clarify the communication.
Unlike zap and startle shock collar training, your dog will be an active participant in training.
Can I punish my dog with an E-Collar?
There is a time and a place for using higher levels as a means to communicate “NO” to your dog.
However, when used correctly, this is a tiny piece of proper E-Collar training (if used at all).
Having a dog ‘cower and run’ when you ‘show them the remote’ is not a positive thing.
With E-Collar training, the remote is never a threat, and scaring your dog into obedience isn’t the goal.
Can I use an E-Collar on a Great Dane puppy?
We recommend starting Great Dane collar training only once your dog (or puppy) has a solid basic obedience foundation.
Your dog should know how to sit, down, come and ‘place’ (or stay) at a basic level, and they should enjoy learning with you!
Once that foundation is in place, you can start your E-Collar conditioning at any time (usually around 4-6 months of age).
Great Dane puppies are incredibly smart and loyal! By implementing modern, gentle training you’ll soon have an incredible gentle giant that can be off-leash with you, anywhere you go.
Do big dogs need more powerful collars?
This myth is brought to you by people with no credible background in canine education!
Large dogs are just as responsive and sensitive to gentle e-collar stimulation as small dogs are.
The best collars for large breed dogs and our gentle giants are also the most gentle! The modern e-collar works incredibly well without harsh corrections.
What about bark collars?
We recommend the use of the Sport Dog bark collar ONLY after you have addressed all of the root reasons behind barking: boredom, anxiety, frustration, aggression, and habit. You can read our Great Dane barking article HERE.
By choosing a different brand for bark corrections, your dog will have a different association with the collar. When your dog barks, the SportDog bark collar will issue a correction. Never use cheap bark collars as they can make dogs suspicious, cautious and nervous.
How to Teach Recall with an E-Collar
First, the dog is conditioned to view the stim sensation, at a low level, as a positive thing. Stim = treats and praise, YAY! If you do this correctly, the dog will feel the stim and get really excited about it.
Second, the dog is taught, using positive reinforcement what the word ‘COME’ means. Starting at a short distance with no distractions, the dog quickly learns without error or correction that COME = good things such as praise, games, and treats.
Third, the dog learns that STIM + COME together = come back, starting at a short distance. Because both STIM and COME = good things, the dog responds.
With just a few short weeks of practice, you can then utilize stim and positive reinforcement to your advantage at increasing distances and around more distractions such as people, dogs, cars and children.
As the dog returns, you can use the dial to gradually reduce the stim sensation, similar to a game of hot and cold…only in this case, ‘cold’ is the goal! .
The dog quickly learns that staying close and coming back = being able to turn the stim sensation both down and eventually off, which is VERY rewarding to the dog.
Remember, with E-Collar training your dog is an ACTIVE participant in the training, and that’s why it works!
Here are some common myths about E-Collar training.
E-Collar training is NOT cruel. The E-Collar is a tool, and like any tool, it can be used correctly or incorrectly.
The goal of E-Collar training is to establish clear communication with your dog in order to have a better relationship and give your dog MORE freedom!
Read on for more common misconceptions about our favorite dog training tool!
Myth: E-Collars just shock the crap out of dogs
Many people believe that the only reason a dog is responsive to their training collar is that you are ‘shocking the crap out of them’ until they come back.
This couldn’t be farther from the truth.
When your cell phone rings, you answer it. It doesn’t hurt you, scare you, punish you, or make you aggressive but it is mildly annoying.
The gentle sensation from the dog collar works the same way. It doesn’t hurt your dog, and just like your cell phone, your dog knows how to turn it off!
All they have to do is come running towards you.
Myth: Your dog is only trained because you forced them
Some people promote the misguided idea that an electric training collar only works because the dog is being punished and forced.
Remember, the stimulation simply replaces pressure from a harness, prong collar, flat collar, or any other type of dog collar.
If we’re going to talk about force, let’s talk about that. Physical restraint is a form of force that is completely removed when you choose off-leash training.
Your dog will be free to move naturally without restrictions, and all they have to do is be responsive to boundaries that you communicate to them using a gentle tactile sensation.
A Great Dane wearing an e-collar is a large dog that is being kept safe, without frustration, pain, or punishment.
As a matter of fact, I’m writing this as we speak with my completely off-leash, intact male Great Dane sitting by my side.
We are on my front porch, in an unfenced yard, with dogs and people walking by. He is calm, happy, and loving life!
Myth: A long leash is more humane
Because people incorrectly believe that all training collars are being used to punish and harm dogs, they will also promote the idea that a long leash is a humane alternative.
While a long leash is necessary during training, it should not be considered the more ‘humane’ choice.
Long leashes can be exceptionally dangerous! If your dog is at the end of a 20-foot lead, you have very little control.
A dog can become tangled or wrapped up by a leash, and excessive force and pressure may be placed on the neck, chest, and shoulders as a result.
Additionally, it is unsafe for dogs to greet each other while on a leash.
Zooming, making circles, running with abandon, zipping through the ocean waves, swimming, climbing up onto or under things, and having a healthy play session with another dog are activities that are unsafe while on any kind of leash (including a long line).
Ditching the leash and using a modern E-Collar instead is the most humane, safe, and effective choice! It is unfair to keep dogs on a leash for their entire life when there is a modern, fantastic alternative!
Myth: Your dog will become aggressive if you use a training collar!
This misguided belief is based on incorrect use. Aggression, frustration, fear, and anxiety can be caused by all forms of training, including positive reinforcement and force-free training!
As a matter of fact, some of the most reactive and frustrated dogs we know were trained using ‘force-free’ methods. It is unfair to place blanket blame on this tool.
If you are turning the stimulation up to aversive levels and intentionally doing so to hurt, scare and punish your dog on a regular basis, without conditioning them to the collar first, then yes.
You can cause aggression.
But used correctly? Nope.
Chances are, you’ll find that your dog is actually calmer, happier, and LESS reactive. Being off-leash is so much more enriching and freeing to dogs than spending life isolated from experiences or trapped by physical restraint devices.
Great Dane TrainingTips & Tricks
Never leave your great dane in their e-collar unattended
Rotate the collar often, and make sure that you have chosen the correct fit for your dog’s neck size. The collar should fit snug and not rub.
Consider investing in contact points made of different metals if your dog has sensitive skin
Use lots of positive reinforcement, and build a solid foundation before getting started!
Visit our E-Collar shop, and feel free to reach out and ask questions!
We ONLY recommend and sell what we use on our own beloved dogs.
All of the products in our shop have been personally tested by us, and we are happy to answer any questions that you may have! We ship dog training collars directly from the manufacturer’s warehouse, so you are sure to get the latest model.
There is a massive difference between an E-Collar and shock collar. It’s frustrating that so many trainers and dog owners misunderstand E-Collars, because they are something that, as primarily positive trainers, we stand behind.
In other words, we don’t believe that they should have the same negative reputation as a tool of force and corrections that shock collars do.
Today, I wanted to address this and clear the air! If you’ve been around our blog a bit, you know that we support responsible E-Collar use, but NOT shock collars.
Interested in learning more about why? Read on…
SHOCK COLLAR:
+ Sharp static shock, similar to a hot electric fence or sticking your finger into an outlet
+ Designed to scare a dog away from a behavior
+ Often painful and always startling
+ Typically offers a warning beep and/or vibrate function, which can mislead dog owners into feeling they are using the tool humanely
+Relies on ‘easy button’ method training, where the dog is the subject of the training, not a participant in it
+Can cause frustration and confusion, especially with poor shock timing
+Scientifically proven to increase fearful and distressed body language, including lip licking, pinning ears, cowering and yelping
+Scientifically proven to increase reactivity and aggression
+Often sold inexpensively online and in pet stores
+Often, though not always also used for invisible fences. Barrier frustration is common.
E-COLLAR:
+ Blunt muscle stimulation, exactly like a TENS unit from a doctor or therapist
+ Designed to be a communication tool, not a correction tool
+ Not painful. Feels like a tickle or tiny ants
+ May offer a warning beep or blunt vibration, which many E-Collar trainers find they never use. Vibration is much more aversive than blunt stim to many dogs
+Relies on the dog having a positive association with the sensation, and being an active participant in training
+Enhances communication and reduces frustration. Allows for more freedom.
+When used correctly, is proven to be a humane and effective training method with no added fear or stress.
+Can increase confidence and freedom and reduce reactivity and aggression
+Only a few companies make E-Collars, they are more expensive and high quality
+Are becoming more common with electric fences, and can be used to teach boundaries.
SHOCK COLLARS & E-COLLARS ARE VERY DIFFERENT TOOLS
Many people resort to a shock collar when they’ve reached their limit with a dog that is exhibiting frustrating and dangerous behaviors such as jumping and running away.
The typical approach to shock collar training includes being ready to hit the ‘easy button’ and startle the dog using beep, vibrate or shock away from an inappropriate behavior.
This action is very rewarding to the person holding the remote, but often frustrating and confusing to the dog.
THE PROBLEM WITH SHOCK COLLARS
When a dog is unsure about the corrections or how to respond to them, they become confused. Many begin to show escalating signs of frustration and fear.
They may yelp, cower, tuck and run or even redirect their anxiety into reactivity. Many continue to ‘act out’ or are labeled as ‘stubborn’ when they continue to repeat incorrect behaviors.
A lot of dog owners will ‘show the dog the remote’ as a threat to push them into compliance. The dog sees it and runs away, often cowering and showing subtle signs of stress. In this common scenario, the threat has become the tool, and that threat is heavily relied upon.
This practice creates a training environment where the dog is under control only because of fear and restrictions, not because they’ve actually been taught right from wrong and given freedom and autonomy.
Shock and startle easy-button training is what gives electronic dog collars a bad name, and it’s a misconception we are out to fix.
Have you made this mistake in training your dog? Don’t stress and simply read on!
E-COLLAR TRAINING
The first step in E-Collar training is to establish the dogs ‘working level’. E-Collars are adjustable. The working level is the point where the dog feels the stimulation.
For many dogs, their ‘working level’ is almost imperceptible to humans. Imagine training your dog with something so gentle! It feels like a small tingle or ants crawling on the skin.
The next step is to pair the stimulation with positive things. Stim, treat. Stim, treat.
The dog quickly becomes EXCITED about the stim!
Proper E-Collar training does NOT rely on force, fear or harsh shock corrections.
Now, you may be asking how a large, in-charge dog could possibly be responsive to this, and that is where the magic of E-Collar training comes into play.
With E-Collars, the dog is an ACTIVE participant in the training. They learn exactly what the stimulation (communication) means and understand how to turn the stimulation down or off by making choices.
Turning the stimulation down and off is very rewarding to them, and many dogs enjoy the mental enrichment aspect. It builds their confidence, especially as the training allows them more freedom.
The stimulation is simply an annoyance; it’s not painful and it doesn’t have to scare them.
They also understand that the stimulation means ‘turn around’ and come back, because doing so always results in good things (especially at first).
When you do have to use a more intense stim to redirect your dog or get his/her attention in a dangerous or inappropriate situation, the dog knows exactly what to do and doesn’t associate the sensation with the environment.
Remember, E-Collar training is a lifestyle. Shock collar training is a bandaid.
Even large and ‘in-charge’ type dogs can make a complete 180 with proper training using positive reinforcement and the E-Collar as a communications tool.
THE BEST E-COLLARS FOR GREAT DANES
We stand by E-Collar Technologies training systems, which offer adjustable blunt stim and multi-dog models.
Shop E-Collars for your Great Dane here! We are an authorized distributor of E-Collar Technologies models and would love to help you give your dog off-leash freedom!
If you’ve previously used a shock collar, that’s ok! Start over again with the E-Collar. It’s a completely different tool and used a completely different way. We are here for you if you have questions!
A properly used E-Collar is MORE humane, MORE effective and LESS aversive than:
vibration mode
a leash
a no-pull harness
a head harness
a prong or choke collar
leash pressure
a collar grab
a harsh verbal correction
a leash pop
a spray bottle
a can of pennies
endless restrictions to freedom and autonomy because of dangerous behaviors such as fence jumping, excessive pulling and running away.
Why do we stand behind E-Collars? Because happy, confident, well-trained dogs that have autonomy and freedom make excellent family pets and good canine citizens.
Natalie and I were having a LONG discussion the other day about dog training (we both LOVE to train our Danes!) and realized that some of the nerdy and more technical aspects of dog training can be really complicated and overwhelming.
People think of training as teaching a puppy to sit, lay down and not pee in the house.
Those are basics. Easy to teach, but in the grand scheme of creating well-behaved, happy and polite family dogs those skills are just the tip of the iceberg.
If you are struggling to move past the cute puppy basics, this post is for you!
FIRST, UNDERSTAND THIS
Operant Conditioning is a big fancy word for ‘how dogs (and people) learn’.
Operant conditioning involves punishment and reward. This is where the magic of dog training comes to play.
Understanding this concept is to put magic in your hands!
We encourage you to let go of the idea that all bad behavior is the result of ‘stubbornness’ or ‘dominance’, or that all punishment means hurting or abusing a dog.
Positive does not necessarily mean ‘YAY’, and negative doesn’t necessarily mean ‘OUCH’ or bad, either!
Positive means to add something. Negative means to take it away.
POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT: This one is easy. You can teach a dog to do nearly anything from recall (COME) and stay to silly tricks by using this quadrant!
Examples:
A treat for sitting
Praise for going potty outside
An ear scratch for sitting calmly while another dog walks by
A frozen stuffed Kong for completing a short stay (and then encouraging the stay to continue) on a mat
A treat, praise, or play session for taking 10 steps in a row by your side (heel position)
You can even use the environment as a reward! For example, if your dog sits politely by the door and waits until you say ‘FREE’ before they run out, their access to the yard is the reward.
Positive reinforcement is NOT all about treats. It’s about adding something the dog likes to encourage the dog to increase a behavior that you want. Use that information to your advantage and think about ways to apply positive reinforcement to your routine outside of ‘sit-treat’.
With all positive reinforcement, once the behavior is ‘installed’ and starts to become reliable, you can reduce the rewards and even eliminate them.
NEGATIVE REINFORCEMENT: This quadrant is one of the most difficult to apply correctly. It involves the removal of something the dog doesn’t want or like, in exchange for them doing the behavior you want. The removal of the negative thing is the reward (reinforcement).
Examples:
Applying pressure to the dog to sit and releasing it when they sit
Using leash pressure to teach the dog to come back or walk nicely on a leash (pressure = turn towards you, pressure relieved is the reward for that behavior)
Asking for a recall by using the stim on an e-collar on continuous, then turning the stim off when the dog returns (or turning it down gradually as they return, like a game of hot-cold)
Asking a dog that is afraid of something to sit or look, then moving them away from the scary thing as a reward for doing that behavior
Pinching a dogs ear until they take a toy into their mouth (also known as a forced retrieve), then letting go of the pinch as soon as they do (relief from the pinch is the reward for doing the behavior)
Opening a door (barrier/restriction) in exchange for polite wait/sit behavior.
Negative reinforcement should always be paired with positive reinforcement.
POSITIVE PUNISHMENT: You use this one every single time you say the word NO to your dog! Positive punishment does not mean ‘sunshine and rainbows’. It means adding (positive, +) something the dog doesn’t like to decrease a behavior.
Examples:
Whacking a dog in the side with a rolled up towel
Throwing a bag of chains on the floor to startle the dog
Spraying a dog in the face with a water bottle
Rolling a dog on its back (alpha roll) / pinning
Deliberately using the vibrate or stim on an e-collar as a correction
Using beep, vibrate or shock on a cheap shock collar as a correction
The collar on an electric fence issuing a shock when a dog crosses the boundary
Jabbing the dog in the neck with two fingers
Popping a prong collar with a leash
Positive punishment can mean anything from a mild correction (‘NO!’) to flat out abuse (kicking a dog or choking it). Tread cautiously with positive punishment! There is never a need to alpha roll/pin or hurt a dog. Punitive positive punishment is what gives many dog trainers a bad name.
Is your trainer relying heavily on positive punishment and calling it ‘discipline’ or ‘dominance’? We encourage you to find a new, more modern trainer!
When using an e-collar, do NOT think of it as an ‘easy’ button. It’s not. You still need to condition your dog (using positive reinforcement) to understand what the stim means and teach the behavior you want.
Only then is it appropriate to use the stim as a corrections tool, and if done correctly you’ll rarely use it that way AT ALL.
NOTE: We DO NOT condone the practice of purchasing and using cheap low quality shock collars, especially to ‘correct’ things such as puppy biting, aggression, resource guarding, crate barking or lunging. Many dogs have been ruined and become aloof, fearful and confused by this practice…plus, without guidance you lose a VALUABLE opportunity to appropriately apply stim as a positive means to communicate and strengthen behaviors. No ethical dog trainer will recommend that you use a cheap shock collar and ‘easy-button’ shock/vibrate/beep training.
Quality e-collars that use a blunt stim (similar to a tens machine and feels more like a muscle stimulation than a shock) are the only electric collars that we recommend. Dogtra, E-Collar Technologies and Garmin are brands to consider, and we recommend using them with guidance and/or diligent research.
NEGATIVE PUNISHMENT: This quadrant is when you remove something the dog finds rewarding in order to decrease a behavior.
Examples:
Locking the trash can so the dog cannot dig through it (removal of the joy of eating trash)
Putting a dog that jumps the fence on a leash in the yard (removal of the reward of jumping the fence)
Turning your back on a puppy that is playing too rough with you/puppy biting or demand barking at you (removal of your attention)
Standing with feet planted on a walk if your dog pulls (removal of the reward involved with moving forward). This one, in a way goes with Negative Reinforcement example above, that leash pressure is relieved when the dog chooses to stop pulling and turn back towards you!
Putting the dog behind a baby gate (removal of access to guests she wants to jump all over)
Negative punishment is a very common, easy way to manage the environment and works best when you are very consistent. While the crate should NEVER be seen as punishment, it is a great tool for management and time outs!
Negative punishment, boundaries, and NOT practicing incorrect behavior go hand in hand! If you are struggling with a dog that jumps, steals, begs or destroys things negative punishment is 100% your friend.
However, negative punishment should not be used in excess; relying on restrictions to freedom, movement and choice is not always the most humane choice. ‘Errorless learning’ and strict behavior management to avoid corrections can be very frustrating, unfair and confusing to dogs so tread cautiously and always look for ways to communicate, guide, teach and train.
POSITIVE VS. BALANCED DOG TRAINING
If we really were to boil this down, there are only a few differences between a ‘positive’ trainer and a ‘balanced’ trainer.
Positive trainers try to not use positive punishment or negative reinforcement. Basically put, they will opt for behavioral management and negative punishment before using anything that may be considered a ‘correction’.
Balanced trainers will use all four quadrants, and that includes the use of e-collars, prongs and other corrections to apply positive reinforcement, positive punishment, negative punishment and negative reinforcement.
GOOD balanced trainers rely heavily on positive reinforcement, and GOOD positive trainers recognize that putting a leash on a dog or withholding a treat until the dog sits is aversive (punishing and yes, ‘balanced’) in some way.
GOOD balanced trainers use the E-Collar as a communications tool, not a corrections one. GOOD positive trainers are realistic about how no-pull and front-clip harnesses work (they are not a positive tool).
The ultimate goal of either trainer should not be to ‘beat dogs into submission’, spoil them, scare them, make them obese with treats or frustrate them…but to teach and guide dogs and owners into a harmonious and healthy relationship.
How can you apply the four quadrants of operant conditioning to strengthen your ability to communicate with your Great Dane?
I am a 99% positive dog trainer and I believe that a properly used E-Collar is an appropriate, helpful and humane training aid for many dogs and owners. Positive trainers, hear me out!
E-Collars are greatly misunderstood! People believe they are a tool of corrections, punishment, and force…and we are ready to change that narrative.
The truth is that I’ve spent YEARS cringing at any kind of electronic collar, judging people for using them, and paying close attention to the unfortunate behavioral problems that resulted from their use.
Aggression, fear, confusion, and aloof behavior seemed common. It bothered me. Like many positive-leaning dog trainers, I was alarmed, frustrated, and sad.
Shock collars are a dated tool that relies on fear, pain, punishment, and force. This blog is NOT pro-shock collar. We are, however,pro-responsibly used E-collar.
E-Collars are a modern invisible leash, and when used properly are less aversive and less harmful than:
-A long leash -A no-pull or front-clip harness -A head collar or Gentle Leader/Halti -Running off and being lost, hurt, or killed -Needless restrictions to freedom and choice done in the name of ‘positive only’ learning
What I had not yet realized at the time was that there was a growing movement of ethical, positive dog trainers who were using electronic collars in a different more dog-focused way. I was also unaware that an E-Collar is a very different device than a shock collar!
These trainers were actively speaking out against shock collars and inhumane training methods that relied on sharp static corrections and punishment.
I noticed that their E-Collar-trained dogs were happy, engaged, confident, and enjoyed freedoms that my dogs could only dream of. They were not aggressive, edgy, anxious, or aloof as the dogs I had seen trained with shock collars and there was no shouting, chasing, frustration, or constant management.
To put this simply, a properly used E-Collar is no more aversive than a collar, leash, or crate. Read on!
E-Collar Training for Dogs
Proper E-Collar training relies heavily on the dog having a POSITIVE association with the sensation. Modern E-Collars have 100 levels to choose from (like the Mini-Educator) so the communication for each dog is completely custom.
E-collars produce muscle stimulation, not a static shock. Most dogs enthusiastically work at stimulation levels that most humans cannot feel when they try it on themselves.
A lot of people say the sensation, when it’s turned up enough for them to feel it, is similar to marching ants or a small tingle.
The dog is taught to associate that feeling with treats and praise. When this is done correctly they become extremely engaged with and excited about the sensation and the training!
(It’s fun to put a proper E-Collar into the hands of somebody who is expecting to be shocked! They are always nervous because they do not yet understand and are anticipating being very uncomfortable. Once they feel it, their minds quickly change and they are laughing, curious, and asking questions!)
E-Collar Conditioning
When the dog has been conditioned to their E-Collar as above, they learn that the stimulation means to turn and come back. redirect and try something different. It becomes a game for them where they are in control of the stimulation, including turning it down and off by enthusiastically returning (recall).
This is a very different approach than ‘shock and startle’, and allows for the handler to communicate clearly with the dog from a larger distance than with any of the other similar options listed above.
Think of an E-Collar like a walkie-talkie for your dog!
MORE AVERSIVE THAN AN E-COLLAR
Now that we understand the basic concept behind how E-Collars feel to the dog are meant to be used, we can look at training tools and methods that are aversive:
Vibration. Many people rely on the ‘vibration’ button because they don’t want to shock their dog. That’s fair, shock collars SUCK. The truth however is that most dogs find a vibration to be MUCH more aversive than the stim (stimulation) from an E-Collar. Subtle signs of stress include lip licking, scratching, head shaking, cowering, hunched posture, stiffness, shaking off, pinned ears, and avoidance.
Shock Collars. Shock collars deliver a sharp static correction that is painful and has been scientifically proven to increase stress, fear, and anxiety. We do NOT recommend shock collars, especially cheap ones from Amazon or pet stores. Shock collar training is a completely different practice and product than E-Collars and E-Collar training.
Head Collars. These provide constant pressure/stimulation to the head and may cause an over-excited or frightful dog to whip their head around and potentially damage their spine. Head collars also require proper conditioning. Many dogs find them extremely aversive to wear and will pant, paw, become frantic, or shut down without proper slow early introductions and desensitization. They work because they are extremely aversive.
No-Pull Harnesses. These harnesses rely on obstructing the way that the dog’s front limbs and shoulders move. They put constant pressure on the chest and impede natural movement, especially if the dog pulls. They are often seen as a ‘positive’ tool, despite this. We do not support the use of no-pull harnesses, nor the notion that they are ‘gentle’ and ‘positive’.
Electric Invisible Fences. Most (not all) invisible fences rely on automated shock corrections. Shock-based invisible fences are known to increase reactivity and barrier frustration in the yard. The shock correction is typically very harsh and many dogs yelp or cower when they experience it. This includes the HALO GPS fence collar, which unlike an E-Collar, does not teach your dog enthusiastic recall – only avoidance.
Long Leashes. Long leashes are necessary before a dog has a reliable recall and in areas where being off-leash is illegal or unsafe. Ultimately, however, off-leash freedom (and the gentle stim from an E-Collar that can become the cue to return from a distance) is MUCH less aversive than always being on a long leash, or having the long leash used as a ‘fishing lure’ to drag the dog back. Dogs on a long leash cannot move the same way as a dog off-leash, and freedom from physical restrictions is wonderful for a dog’s mental and physical health and condition.
Collars and Harnesses. Dogs that pull or lunge against any kind of harness or collar may feel pressure and tension on their neck, chest, armpits, stomach, and throat. Leash reactivity is often directly related to the built-in physical restrictions and tension of the leash and collar, a sensation that makes many dogs anxious and uncomfortable. On the flip side, a dog that is trained with gentle stim to recall or redirect is more likely able to enjoy off-leash freedom and outdoor exploration, activities which will always be more enriching and less stressful to most dogs than a restrictive walk on pavement.
Squirt Bottle. Squirt bottles, like shock collars, teach dogs to fear the circumstances and may even teach them to fear water and being sprayed. Many dog owners rely on the squirt bottle as a threat and the dog never really learns right from wrong, which is aversive in and of itself. Unlike E-Collars, no positive association is ever made to being squirted in the face.
Errorless Learning/BehaviorManagement. Management is an important and necessary part of dog training! However, when management is used as a supposed ‘positive’ alternative to communication (and yes, appropriate corrections), it may be inhumane and unfair. Read on…
ENDLESS RESTRICTIONS
The common response from trainers who wish to avoid any kind of stimulus that could be seen as aversive (including the E-Collar on a low level, used on a dog taught to associate the tingle with treats) will be to advocate for strict behavior management and a positive only approach.
Behavior management includes leashes, escape-proof harnesses, martingale collars, withholding access, gates and crates which can all be used to make sure that the dog cannot make a mistake (such as slipping a collar or jumping a fence).
These are all tools and techniques that can be aversive in and of themselves.
Management is an important part of proper training, however, many overlook how aversive many management techniques can be for the dog.
Dogs need us to communicate with them, and that includes establishing boundaries and giving them the ‘full picture’ of the world they live in. Dogs that live restricted lives with no freedom to make mistakes can become confused and often become needlessly shut down, frantic, anxious, frustrated or reactive.
Isolating a dog from experiences in the name of the long haul ‘positive only/errorless learning’ approach may actually be inhumane and will almost definitely be more aversive to a dog than communication from an E-Collar paired with positive reinforcement.
Endless restrictions to freedom and experiences suck.
FIGARO, THE FENCE JUMPER
We have a friendly, confident, positively trained (clicker + treats) Great Dane with great recall and polite manners. He’s young, full of life, athletic and awesome. I BELIEVE in positive training!
One day he learned that he could get over the fence, into the neighbor’s yard to play with their terrier. The neighbor was NOT amused.
To address this, Figaro spent the next three weeks on a long leash in the yard while I taught him new fence boundaries and prevented the behavior. I used a clicker and taught him to redirect away from the fence and to ignore the neighbor’s dog. IT WORKED!
But the entire time my sweet Dane baby was heartbroken. He HATED being on a leash in the yard. He hunched his head, walked slowly, and wouldn’t stay outside with me for long. For most of the three weeks, he moped around the house. This was despite the fact that I did everything I could to make it positive and fun, and despite the fact that anywhere else in the world he was perfectly happy to be on a leash.
If all you’ve ever known was freedom to explore the backyard, how crappy would it be to suddenly have no freedom at all?
The long-haul positive approach rooted in strict management and behavior prevention ended up being aversive to him, and he’s not alone!
I now know that a highly positive approach paired with conditioning to the E-Collar (so he could be off-leash while learning and have the stim available to redirect him if needed) would have been less aversive, faster, more humane, and more appropriate for him.
Do not buy into the marketing that tells you a long leash and strict management are better for a dog than an E-Collar! Modern technology and education is changing this narrative.
OH, BUT WHAT ABOUT THE STUDIES?
For every study out there claiming that shock collars and E-Collars are bad, there is another study claiming that they are perfectly acceptable.
These studies are often flawed. No distinction is made between a shock collar and the E-Collar (they often lump the two devices into the same, which is a massive fault in the origins of the study), and no practice is made of making sure the Electric collar trained dogs in the study had been properly and positively conditioned to the collar in the first place.
Most studies that indicate elevated stress levels associated with electronic collars were done on dogs where the ‘Easy button’ method was used, and training only took place over days or at best, weeks.
In other words, the training method being ‘studied’ often involved asking a dog for a recall, offering very little positive reinforcement, requiring a lot of dogs in a short period of time and using the stim or shock to ‘punish’ them for not coming when called.
Of course that is going to elevate stress levels, especially in the context of the unusual environment of a study! The stim is not meant to be used as a punishment, and shock collars will never be an appropriate training tool. So comparing those studies to the way modern, positive trainers are using E-Collars isn’t fair.
The correct approach to E-Collar training a recall involves creating a positive association including happy, engaged body language to the stim (R+), developing a foundation in recall using treats and praise (R+), using a long leash to prevent errors, and then teaching the dog that stim + come = come back (R+, again).
Many E-Collar trainers then strengthen the recall by also teaching the dog that the feeling of the stim (marching ants) becomes weaker the closer the dog gets to the handler (making recall even MORE rewarding through a very gentle version of ‘negative reinforcement’ where the dog is completely in control of the stim, not the handler).
Is the stimulation annoying? At some levels, yes, it can be. But as above, so is a long leash. The difference here is that the E-Collar provides freedom and choice, while the long leash does not.
THINK OF IT LIKE A CLICKER, TREATS OR BRAIN GAMES.
E-collars do not have to be aversive, painful, or punishing. It is a huge mistake to use them that way.
We think there is space for E-Collars in the positive trainer’s toolbox, especially with the knowledge that the stim is less aversive to most dogs than many traditional techniques and tools. Many owners and trainers report that after just a few weeks of E-Collar conditioning, their dogs are happier, calmer, easier to live with, and much, much more confident!
E-Collars can lead to more freedom; natural movement, unobstructed by collars and harnesses, and well-trained dogs that understand how to play the stim AND the treat game.
Today we are providing an EZ 900 Educator E-Collar review for Great Dane owners (or for any dog lover!) This is our honest, unsponsored review of the Easy Educator E-Collar model 900, AKA the ‘EZ EDUCATOR’ series from E-Collar technologies.
As Great Dane lovers, it’s important to us that owners are choosing the most humane tools and training methods for their dogs.
Our training relies heavily on positive reinforcement, but we also believe that dogs appreciate it when they know what their boundaries are.
EZ Educator ET-900 E-Collar Review
We believe in educated ownership and don’t support use of any kind of inexpensive electric shock collar as a corrective ‘easy button’. We do stand behind properly used E-Collars though, with the belief that humane, effective, and positive off-leash educator training involves conditioning the dog to the stimulation and teaching the dog to understand that it means GOOD things, not punishment.
The stimulation from a quality remote dog training collar will be blunt and feel like a small tingle or muscle twitch, not a sharp static shock.
Fun fact: A properly used modern remote collar is less aversive than a long leash, head harness, no-pull harness, or squirt bottle.
We believe in this training method because off-leash freedom = a beautiful life for you and your family pet.
Not only that but momentary stimulation is an incredibly gentle replacement for physical restraint. If your dog could safely be off-leash, and all they have to do is be responsive to mild stimulation levels only when needed, then why wouldn’t you consider it?
The Easy Educator dog collar ships quickly and is packaged in a beautiful box that has a small footprint (less waste!).
Remote collars can often feel like a ‘harsh’ or ‘utilitarian’ type of tool, but this packaging offers a sense of positivity and aesthetics that speak to confident, happy family dogs (not scared dogs that are afraid of the remote or being “shocked into submission“).
We are looking at the Easy Educator TWO dog system for this review, however the 900 series Educator collars come in a one, two, three or four dog system.
With multi-dog systems you can control each dog independently from the same remote.
ET-900 Inside the Box
Inside the Educator remote dog trainer box is:
The manual
Receiver (1, 2, 3 or 4 depending on what system you choose)
One waterproof ergonomic transmitter (AKA the remote)
One Biothane collar strap for each receiver, all in a different color so each dog has their own device
A micro USB charger for the remote & a cable with a splitter to charge the receiver(s)
A lanyard
Large and small contact points for each receiver (customize for each dog)
A tool to change the contact points
The included biothane collars are rugged, washable, and waterproof. Biothane is the perfect material for E-Collars, as many E-Collar-trained dogs enjoy adventures outdoors that involve dirt, mud, and water!
The collars are definitely long enough to fit any Great Dane and can be cut down in length if needed. We highly recommend upgrading the straps to bungee straps, which offer more flexibility and a better fit.
Is the Educator EZ 900 quality?
The receivers that the dog wears feel well-made and are lightweight! Educator brand collars use the most significant technological advancement in remote dog training collars available; we like to compare them to cell phones. Educator collars are the latest iPhone.
A lot of dedication and engineering went into the tapping sensation of the EZ 900, making this a gentle, effective trainer for your pet dog. The technology used in Educator collars is similar to that of a medical-grade TENS device, which uses electrical currents to stimulate the muscle.
In training, this sensation is often referred to as ‘pressure’ or ‘stimulation’.
One thing we love is that EACH collar receiver can be completely customized to the dog that will be wearing it! The advanced remote is a complete system that allows you to program different settings for each dog you are training.
This means you’ll be able to apply different stimulation modes including momentary stimulation, continuous stimulation, momentary boosted stimulation, beep or vibrate at sufficient value for each dog.
The EASY 900 is a medium-range trainer with a 1/2 mile range with instant stimulation options so that you can communicate with your dog from afar.
Good remote collar training will require precise control; we like that there are 100 levels to choose from so you can fine-tune the blunt stimulation that your dog will feel (and respond to).
The contact points are made of quality metal and can be replaced with other sizes and metals, depending on your dog. You can easily change contact points with the included tool, and other options are available including wings (for long-haired dogs) and comfort pads (for short-haired dogs).
How do I program my Easy Educator EZ 900?
We recommend programming your primary button for each dog to continuous stimulation and then learning how to use that button for a single instant stimulation ‘tap’, continuous mode or dynamic (continuous with increasing pressure).
Secondary buttons for each dog can be programmed to tone, beep, or vibrate.
We like to use the single tapping sensation (tap tap tap) on a very low level as a reminder to a dog to follow, look or pay attention.
Continuous stimulation at low levels (or higher in distracting environments) can be used for off-leash recall from a distance.
Dynamic continuous pressure (that increases) works well as a warning to a dog that they must stop what they are doing and redirect to something else.
Tone can also be used as a recall cue, similar to a whistle. For most dogs, including deaf ones, the vibration mode is aversive compared to low-level stimulation modes. We recommend saving vibration for when your dog is doing something dangerous such as running into a road or rudely chasing another dog.
Both the receivers AND the remote are completely waterproof, and we have heard that the remote will float!
Your dog can safely swim in the Educator remote collar without fear of being ‘zapped’ by the cheap faulty electronics seen from other brands. E-Collar Technologies stands behind this and will support you with this purchase forever.
The company also states that the Easy Educator is impact-proof. If you drop it, you don’t have to worry about it not working, malfunctioning and running too ‘hot’, and hurting your dog.
This is a BIG reason we stand behind quality E-Collars and NEVER inexpensive ‘dog training shock devices’ found on Amazon or in pet stores.
Easy Educator Features
There is a maximum stimulation setting of 100. Compare this to other collars on the market that may have just 5-10 levels!
The top of the receiver has a connection spot (a red dot) that connects the receiver and collar electronically, and LED lights that blink green when a connection has been made between the training collar and the remote.
The light on the receiver can also be turned on as a night tracking light so that you can see your off-leash dog in the dark!
The waterproof ergonomic transmitter remote included with the EZ Educator dog training collar is yellow and has a large digital display.
Just like the collar receiver, the remote is lightweight, impact-proof (and waterproof).
The bar shaped transmitter remote has a 1/2 mile range. Unless you are working with hunting, sport training, and tracking, few dog owners need more off-leash roaming space than that.
Although the receiver is small (providing stealth operation, if you are concerned about uneducated naysayers), it provides plenty of stimulation for most dogs, even 150lb Great Danes!
The blunt stimulation is a gentle sensation that doesn’t result in yelping or excessive normal head jerking often seen from other training collars. We prefer this brand for the very clean stimulation and tapping sensation employed during use. No sharp static shocks!
Adjustable Mode, Tone, and Stimulation Levels
On the top is the dial which allows you to adjust the stimulation level up and down. The dial requires some effort to move, which will prevent you from accidentally dialing the stim up too high.
Precise control of stimulation levels is incredibly important.
Educator E-Collars have lock and set features that can be programmed to ‘lock’ at a chosen stimulation level so that you cannot accidentally turn it up too high (and startle your dog).
Each dog is assigned their own buttons and you can control each dog completely independently. The buttons are recessed behind a rubber casing, which makes them waterproof and also safe from accidental ‘butt dialing’.
The ET-900 series training collar offers an adjustable tone and adjustable vibrate mode as well. Programming allows you to adjust how these buttons (which are ergonomically placed) will be used for each dog.
There is also a function where the stim can begin at a low level (so as not to scare your dog) and have it automatically increase to a set level.
The included momentary boost feature can also be customized to each dog, so you maintain precise control.
Don’t forget the night tracking light, which is fantastic for sport training and dogs that are often off-leash in the dark.
We believe the EZ EASY EDUCATOR 900 series is the most high-tech E-Collar available, and perfect for dog owners who like customizations, options, and geeky tech stuff!
The defining differences between stim collars and shock collars can be confusing, especially because there is so much misinformation out there about how remote dog training collars are used.
Stim collars such as the ones offered by E Collar Technologies use a significant technological advancement that changes traditional ‘shock’ into a much more gentle stimulation sensation. This sensation is so gentle that most humans cannot feel it themselves!
With this new more modern form of dog off-leash training utilizing a complete system from remote trainer to positive reinforcement, the desired response is positive, not negative.
In other words, your dog, with the right training and conditioning, will respond with enthusiasm and excitement!
This stimulation feels like a tapping sensation, not a sharp static shock, and can be used for recall training, boundary training, and more.
Other training collars do not offer the same unique features and rely instead on punishing, scaring, and hurting your dog. An Educator is NOT a shock collar!
Even a smart, stubborn dog can learn how to recall reliably in different environments, and will come running back to you ready for more!
How do you use the EZ Educator ez 900?
We’ve said this before and we’ll say it again. E-Collar training is a lifestyle and requires that you change your mindset about how a tool like this will work on your dog.
Easy button shock collar training with cheap devices from Amazon is NOT a method that we support for several reasons.
Dogs trained with shock collars applied as a means to startle and punish can easily become aloof, nervous, anxious, over-excited, frustrated, or even aggressive.
Cheap shock collars are unreliable and more likely to malfunction and hurt your dog. They provide a sharp static shock that causes many dogs to (understandably) show signs of stress and begin to act on it.
Your dog should never be afraid of your remote, their collar receiver, or of what happens when they are wearing it.
Correct stimulation collar training requires a change in how you communicate but it will PAY OFF!
Not only will you want to learn the ins and outs of your E-Collar remote and how it works, but it’s also important to put some time into actually working with your dog so that your dog knows that stimulation is a good thing and knows how to respond to it.
We recommend upgrading the included biothane collar strap to one with a bungee for a better and more comfortable fit for your dog.
E-Collars are an easy operation communication tool, like giving a cell phone to your dog. If you want off-leash freedom and confident, curious, and happy family dogs, this method is for you.
Why should I use a remote training collar?
We always like to mention that we use a lot of positive reinforcement while training our own dogs. Proper remote collar training uses a lot of positive reinforcement.
Off-leash recall, boundary training, and redirection are just some of the reasons we recommend remote collar training for all Great Danes. Unlike a harness, collar or leash, this is one tool that doesn’t rely on physical restraint and cannot harm your dog!
Are dog correction collars cruel?
Absolutely not! There are many things people do to dogs that are actually cruel. This is not one of them.
Training collars from high-quality companies such as Educator Technologies use different technology and blunt stimulation modes that work in a different way compared to inexpensive and painful shock collars.
Well-trained dogs that can be safely off-leash are free of physical restraint, which can cause frustration and even anxiety. Not only that, but nothing compares to the enrichment a dog receives off-leash! Advanced remote collar training is life-changing for dogs and owners.
Aggressive Dog Aversion Training
Some people purchase a remote dog training collar because they are at the end of their rope with a dog that is aggressive or reactive.
There is a huge difference between aggressive dog aversion training (which involves a lot of unfair punishment), and correct training with a modern remote collar.
The last thing you want to do is turn up the dial to maximum stimulation and hope it grabs the attention of your aggressive dog! This kind of training can make things much worse.
Instead, it is important to give your dog skills to build on: basic obedience such as touch, sit, heel, down, leave it, and come make a great foundation. After that, you can start building confidence and indifference to the world with positive counter-conditioning and desensitization.
From there, you can use your remote dog training collar at low levels to communicate and redirect your dog back to you as needed. These unique features, paired with positive reinforcement, set the Educator ez 900 apart from traditional shock collars.
Are there e-collars that don’t shock?
Shock and muscle stimulation are two very different things.
One is a sharp static zap, the other feels like a tap, tickle, or tiny ants crawling around. We prefer the Educator training collar models over traditional inexpensive shock because they offer a gentle tapping sensation.
The stimulation sensation from a high-quality remote dog training collar is non-aversive and can be used for communication. It is an effective trainer that replaces the pressure from a leash, harness, or collar!
How do you train a dog with an E-Collar?
We recommend starting out by finding the lowest level where your dog has the desired response. Most dogs are enthusiastic and responsive between levels 3 and 10, and this is a sufficient value for getting started. The tapping sensation employed by this collar is incredibly gentle and feels more like a brief pulse than a shock.
Keep in mind that you will not likely feel the sensation if you try it yourself until you dial it up to higher stimulation levels well beyond what you need for training your dog.
Pair this gentle tapping sensation with treats, and gradually increase the criteria as you teach your dog what the sensation means. The collar becomes a cell phone for your dog that replaces leash pressure, not a punishment tool!
Boosted stimulation mode can be used when your dog is distracted, and maximum stimulation is available in case of an emergency (for example, your dog is trying to run into traffic, yikes!).
We have training resources available, and we also highly recommend watching Larry Krohn on Youtube for the best and most positive remote training advice!
Your dog training collar offers precision control and has a boost feature for when you and your dog are in higher distraction areas (kind of like turning up the volume on your cell phone), momentary stimulation, and continuous stimulation.
What is the difference between the Mini Educator and the Educator E Collar?
The Mini-Educator dog training collar uses the same advanced technology as the Easy 900, in a more compact and elegant package.
The Mini-Educator remote is round instead of bar-shaped, and it offers only slightly fewer features.
We think the Mini-Educator (or the Micro Mini-Educator with the waterproof miniature collar receiver for small dogs) is a solid choice for dog owners who are new to off-leash remote training.
The Mini-Educator still offers a tracking light, quick emergency stimulation options, transmitter beeper mode, and the brief pulse sensation that educator 1/2 mile collars are known for, in a smaller package.
A mini-Educator remote training collar. Slightly different than the ET-900 but still a fantastic option.
Which educator collar is best for my dog?
If you value simplicity, elegance, and easy operation, choose the Mini-Educator (one dog training collar) or the Educator (just like the Mini-Educator, but for two dogs). If you have a dog under 15lbs, choose the Micro Mini-Educator.
If you like features, extra customization options, or have more than 2 dogs, the Easy 900 Educator is the way to go.
There are many tools used in dog training (leashes, treats and crates come to mind), and some are more controversial than others. If I had to take a guess, I’d say that the E-Collar tops the list of most controversial training tools.
Just like any other tool (including leashes and yes, treats) mistakes and incorrect use can have serious consequences for a dog. Confusion, fear, frustration, aggression and health problems can result from outdated or misguided training methods.
Today, we’re chatting about some common E-Collar mistakes so that you can avoid them with YOUR dog! We believe in the modern, positive use of E-Collars as a remote invisible leash and want to change the way people think about them for the better.
E-COLLAR MISTAKE: TRAINING A DOG THAT DOESN’T KNOW ANY SKILLS
E-Collar training is going to be an exercise in frustration for dogs that don’t have basic skills down at a beginner level. Before E-Collar training begins, your dog should be able to execute the following commands in a low-distraction environment:
Sit, Down, Stand, Touch
Place (lay on a bed or mat)
Leave it
Drop it
Wait (at the door)
Stay (30 seconds)
Basic leash manners (loose heel position)
Come (in a low distraction area, 10 feet away)
These don’t have to be perfect, but the dog should know them and understand ‘how to learn’. It’s ok if your dog is unable to do these things outside of your home or yard, just yet.
Why is this important? Because it shows three things: one, that the dog knows how to learn (and you know how to teach it), two that the dog has foundational skills to build upon, and three, that your dog has built a positive relationship with you as the handler.
We do not care what crackhead alpha dominance franchised reality television dog trainer you learned from that told you otherwise, the E-Collar should never be used to teach basic obedience commands. All of these things are extremely easy to teach in your living room using nothing but praise, treats and toys.
Always start there! The foundation you build will pay off with advanced obedience down the line.
E-COLLAR MISTAKE: THE EASY BUTTON
Unfortunately, this is the most COMMON mistake in the world of E-Collars, and the reason why so many people are against this tool.
The E-Collar is NOT an easy button.
You should never, ever slap a shock or E-Collar on a dog and start zapping them when they step out of line.
2001 called and they want their dog training back. Seriously.
A proper E-Collar has so much more potential than this…and so does your dog!
Don’t waste the amazing capabilities of the E-Collar as an invisible leash by resorting to poorly timed punitive corrections. Doing so may feel good in the moment, but it rarely addresses the root cause of the behavior (fear, anxiety, prey-drive and a lack of training, boundaries and management).
RUN from any garbage trainer that puts an electric collar on your dog and encourages you to light up the remote for puppy biting, running away, reactivity, leash lunging, digging in the trash, barking or otherwise.
Look, we get it, you are frustrated…but take it easy. Meeting training problems with hot corrections and using the remote as a threat isn’t the most humane or effective route to solve behavior problems.
Lay off the easy button and come with us into the current decade of dog training, we are here to help you!
E-COLLAR MISTAKE: BUYING A SHOCK COLLAR
Newsflash, shock collars and E-Collars are TWO different things.
Shock collars are absolute garbage. They deliver a sharp, punishing electric shock and are meant to be used as a tool of corrections. See above.
E-Collars cost more (typically $199+) because they deliver a gentle, blunt muscle stimulation meant to be used as a communication, not a correction.
If you are struggling with behavior, buying a shock collar may feel like the last resort option, but we promise you, the properly used E-Collar can help you with behavior AND more…all without unfairly punishing your dog.
We know those cheap $30-$50 shock collars on Amazon are appealing as you watch your giant beast of a dog destroy the trash, lunge at a chihuahua and run out the front door…but we have a little secret.
Those are training and management problems, and attempting to fix them by hurting your dog is a bandaid. Plus, properly used E-Collars offer so much more. Off-leash freedom, better communication and a happier dog that truly understands what is being asked. We want you to have this and more.
Many people view E-Collars as a punishment tool, and are completely misinformed about the power of using it as a positive communication tool.
When the stimulation felt from the collar is associated with good things, through a process called E-Collar Conditioning, hundreds of doors open up for you and your dog.
The dog is given a reason to LISTEN to the stimulation and knows how to respond to it…rather than learning to fear it (and run away from it OR the remote, yikes)!
When a dog responds positively to low levels of stimulation, you can communicate with your dog in a much more powerful way than you can by waiting to shock the crud out of your dog for messing up.
With correct E-Collar training, dogs are enthusiastically developing advanced off-leash obedience skills using a sensation that feels as gentle as a few ants crawling on skin. Not shocks or corrections.
That’s a fact. Do not skip the conditioning phase, it’s incredibly important. It’s also FUN, easy to do, and will turn your E-Collar into an invisible leash.
E-COLLAR MISTAKE: NOT USING POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT
Positive reinforcement using treats, praise and play is an integral part of developing amazing, confident, happy off-leash family dogs.
You cannot just put an E-Collar on a dog and zap them into submission.
TRUTH TIME: we are pretty angry with the low-life dog trainers who promote that nonsense, especially when they disguise it as ‘discipline’.
Dogs that are rewarded for correct behaviors learn faster and are more enthusiastic, predictable and well-balanced. Positive reinforcement is the scientifically studied basis for how ALL living things learn. Plants are rewarded for finding the sun. Children are rewarded for being polite in school. Humans are rewarded for hard work with cash bonuses.
Dogs can be rewarded with affection, food or a quick game of tug. All basic obedience skills are easy to teach using positive reinforcement. With effective E-Collar training, positive reinforcement is used to teach the dog how to respond to, and turn off the stimulation.
E-COLLAR MISTAKE: USING VIBRATE
Many people who buy a shock or E-Collar out of desperation to fix behavior problems will rely heavily on beep and vibrate.
They often say that they would never ‘use shock’ and that the vibrate gets the dogs attention. This makes them feel better about using a punitive correction tool.
However, vibrate is often actually MORE aversive to a dog, and will cause MORE stress than a low-level stimulation that the dog has been conditioned to respond to (see our note about conditioning above).
Vibration seems harmless but it’s actually very startling and annoying. It is not uncommon to see stress signals, including cowering, hunching, tail tucking and pinning ears. Try it yourself. Feel the vibration sensation, then feel the stimulation at a level 7 (on E-Collar Technologies, the level many dogs work at). You won’t be able to feel the stimulation, but you WILL feel the vibration.
Vibrate and beep mode are not more humane. We don’t use either mode with our dogs, and most ethical E-Collar trainers don’t either. Be like a legitimate dog trainer and reprogram those buttons on your E-Collar to something less aversive.
E-COLLAR MISTAKE: STIM CITY
Many people start to bump the stim level when ‘holes’ in their training pop up (most often due to a lack of conditioning and positive reinforcement, or because the collar is not fitted properly).
They may believe that the dog is being stubborn, defiant, dominant, or ‘large and in charge’ and they will respond by dialing up the heat.
It’s easy to fall into this trap. But remember this; eventually you’re going to run out of heat on that stim collar, and the dog still won’t understand what it is supposed to be doing.
If you find yourself resorting to stim city, take a vacation from the E-Collar and go back to basics.
After a few weeks of conditioning and diligent training, many people report that their dog responds beautifully, enthusiastically and consistently to low-levels of stimulation, that they rarely if ever have to actually use the tool on their dog, and that it’s there simply as a ‘backup’ device.
Remember: E-Collars are a modern wireless leash, not a corrective device.
E-COLLAR MISTAKE: FIXING AGGRESSION
The absolute WORST thing you can do with an E-Collar is to put it on a dog and then dial up the stim when they are being reactive or aggressive.
This is true for leash aggression, dog aggression, human aggression, aggression between two dogs in a home and aggression towards children.
Never, ever use an E-Collar to ‘correct’ a behavior that is based on emotion. You will make the problem worse in the long run.
Aggression is a fear-based response that requires diligent, thoughtful management and professional training, NOT shock or E-Collars.
E-Collars can be used with fearful and aggressive dogs, but only with conditioning and positive reinforcement, when the dog is not being fearful, aggressive or reactive, as a tool to teach reliable off-leash skills.
If you found one of those garbage dog trainers that tells you to use high-level stim to correct the dog for reacting in some way, or has you ready to hit the ‘easy button’ when your two house dogs go after each other, get your money back. That crap is what gives E-Collars and dog trainers a bad name.
LEARN E-COLLAR THE RIGHT WAY
We have an ever-growing library of free E-Collar training resources to help you create a beautiful relationship with your dog.
